In San Diego’s typically fast-paced rental market, recent slowdowns have caught many landlords off guard. Vacancies are sitting longer, prospective renters are taking more time to decide, and competition among property owners is heating up. The smartest move landlords can make in this climate is to work with an experienced San Diego property management company. Please contact us at Onyx Property Management. We serve all of San Diego County, including Chula Vista, Oceanside, Carlsbad, and the surrounding areas.
Why is the San Diego Rental Market Getting Tougher?
Onyx • October 9, 2025
As most real estate investors and local owners may have noticed, the San Diego rental market is experiencing a shift, with properties taking longer to rent and increased competition among landlords. This trend is driven by rising vacancy rates, a surge in rental concessions, and evolving renter behaviors.
Our data tells us that the average time to rent a unit has increased, even with strategic marketing and responsive showings. Still, properties are staying on the market longer than in previous years. This slowdown is attributed to a combination of factors, including an influx of new rental properties and shifting renter preferences.
With vacancy rates rising, landlord concessions becoming necessary, and rental values settling into more consistency, how can
property owners remain competitive?
We want to focus your attention on two key areas where we see potential:
- Making your property more competitive through upgrades and improvements.
- Creative marketing strategies to direct attention towards your rentals.
- Working hard to retain existing tenants to avoid turnover and vacancy.
Let’s take a closer look at how these things may help.
Providing a San Diego Rental Property Tenants Can’t Resist
One of the most effective ways to keep your San Diego rental homes occupied and tenants interested in what you have to offer is through targeted property improvements. Whether you're
managing a single-family rental or a multi-unit building, strategic upgrades can help you attract tenants quickly to your property.
- Focus on First Impressions
Curb appeal matters. A well-maintained exterior signals to potential tenants that they won’t want to miss the inside. Simple upgrades like fresh paint, modern lighting, and landscaping can make a big difference. In San Diego’s climate, low-maintenance, drought-tolerant landscaping is not only attractive but cost-effective.
- Modernize Kitchens and Bathrooms
These two areas are often where a tenant’s immediate attention goes. You don’t need a full remodel if your property is in generally good condition. Updating plumbing and light fixtures, new paint, adding a backsplash, or repainting cabinets can go a long way. Stainless steel appliances and energy-efficient upgrades are especially appealing in today’s market.
- Add In-Demand Amenities
Washer/dryer units, air conditioning, and smart home features like keyless entry or thermostats can set your rental apart. In San Diego, where lifestyle is everything, amenities that add convenience and comfort can significantly boost interest.
- Energy Efficiency = Tenant Savings
Tenants are increasingly eco-conscious. Installing energy-efficient windows, insulation, LED lighting, an electric car charger and
adding solar panels not only can reduce utility bills but also shows prospective renters that you’re invested in sustainability. This is something that resonates in this environmentally minded city.
Stay informed about what renters in your area value. Longer vacancies are often preventable with proactive maintenance and smart upgrades.
Expert Marketing for San Diego Rentals
Strategic marketing can make the difference between a listing that lingers and one that leases quickly. Our tips include:
- Invest in High-Quality Photos
Most renters start their search online, and listings with professional photos get far more attention. Highlight natural light, modern features, and outdoor spaces, especially in scenic neighborhoods. If possible, consider a short walk-through video to create an immersive experience.
- Social Media and Ads Boosting
Platforms like Instagram and Facebook are perfect for showcasing your property. Local hashtags like #SanDiegoLiving or #SDRentals can boost visibility. A well-timed, targeted post can reach hundreds of local renters in a matter of hours. Social media also allows you to engage with potential tenants in a way that general online rental platforms do not. Paying a fee for ads boosting allows your property to show up more frequently and higher up on property searches on popular rental sites.
- Offer Incentives to Spark Interest
A discount on the first month’s rent, a reduced pet fee, or a complimentary cleaning service can motivate quicker decisions, especially if your competition isn’t offering the same perks. These limited-time promotions also give your listing a sense of urgency.
With professional photos, a strong social media presence, ads boosting and attractive move-in incentives, your San Diego rental can compete in a crowded market.
Retaining San Diego Tenants
In a market like the one we are currently experiencing; tenant retention should be your top priority. Here’s why.
1.Turnover Is Expensive
The average cost of turning over a rental unit, including lost rent, cleaning, repairs, marketing, and leasing fees, can easily exceed a full month’s rent. In a slower market, that vacancy period may stretch longer than expected..
2. Great Tenants Are Harder to Find
With more units available and renters being more selective, finding high-quality tenants takes more time and effort. Meanwhile, your reliable renter is already paying on time, keeping the unit in good shape, and minimizing your headaches.
3. Small Incentives Go a Long Way.
Retaining tenants doesn’t always require major concessions. A modest rent increase, a simple property upgrade, or just clear and respectful communication can make tenants feel valued and more likely to stay. Make an effort to create a great rental experience for your residents and ask them about their plans months before the lease ends so you’re not surprised.
4. Stability Brings Peace of Mind
A stable rental means steady cash flow, fewer unexpected expenses, and more time to focus on growing your portfolio.
In a cooling market, tenant loyalty is a landlord’s best asset. Prioritize communication, offer value, and build strong relationships. It’s not just good business. In a market like this one, it’s your competitive edge.
Through tenant retention, smart marketing, and well-chosen upgrades and updates, it will make it less likely that you would be affected by the slower market in San Diego. There is still a large pool of tenants who want to live here.
We are here to help military landlords navigate these key areas while maximizing rental property value in San Diego.
The California Balcony Inspection Law, also known as SB 721 and SB 326, is reshaping how landlords approach structural safety.
With the right strategy, you can increase rent while maintaining tenant satisfaction and loyalty. I
Let’s talk about how California’s home insurance crisis is impacting landlords in Encinitas, and what we can do about it.
Let’s talk about the key signs that indicate it might be time to switch your property management company in San Diego.
We’re talking about AB 2347, and the new eviction laws that California landlords must work around in order to remove a tenant from their rental property.
Let's discuss risk management and how to implement best practices for your multi-unit properties in San Diego.
As a new real estate investor, there’s a lot to consider. And we’re here to help you.
Most importantly, let’s discuss how to protect your assets in a world where anything is possible. Let’s explore the key information required to protect your real estate investment and your financial interests.
We strive to demystify property management fees. Let’s talk about why our fee structure at Onyx Property Management works well for the owners and investors who choose us.
