When Will I See ROI on My Rental Property?

Onyx • March 10, 2023
When Will I See ROI on My Rental Property? - Article Banner

Generally, your San Diego rental property begins making money for you as soon as you buy it. However, we know that it is not always easy to see your return on investment (ROI) right away. This can be frustrating for real estate investors. 


How soon can you feel like you’re making money when you
rent out a property?


The answer may not be exactly what property owners want to hear, and that is: it depends. 


The point at which you actually begin to see ROI on your investment depends on a number of factors, such as whether there’s an outstanding mortgage or if you needed to do extensive renovations to the property.


There’s no single ROI formula that will tell you when your property starts making money for you. But, if you consider the following factors, you may see how buying and holding real estate allows you to gradually build wealth. You may not get rich quick when
investing in San Diego real estate, but you will make money over the long term. 


Here’s how you can determine your ROI. 


How is Return on Investment Calculated?


Your return on investment, or ROI, can best be described as the profit you earn annually as a percentage of the total amount of cash you invested into the property. 


This is why there are differing timelines for investors. If you bought a single-family rental home in cash, your ROI will likely be much lower than if you financed the property. Your mortgage or loan leverages what you earn because you have not invested too much cash into the property at the point of purchase. 


Currently, the real estate market has some of the highest prices we have seen. So, it will likely take you longer to see a return. This is based on current purchase price and what investors will have to spend to acquire a home in San Diego. If you bought a property at a lower price point, during a less competitive market, you’d see a larger return faster. 


In San Diego’s rental market, you will likely see a positive return after you’ve rented the property out for a few years, as long as you keep the home occupied with good tenants and you can reliably raise your ROI a little each year. 

 

Methods of Measuring Returns on San Diego Investment Homes


There are different benchmarks that investors use to measure their own ROI. Most experts like to use the cash on cash return model to establish whether they’re earning any money on their investment property. 


The formula isn’t complicated. 


Your cash on cash return is the annual net operating income less loan payments from operations divided by the total cash invested in the property. 


The cash on cash return formula looks like this:


Annual NOI - Debt / Total Invested Cash = Cash on Cash Return


Remember, your return will grow over time. If you can see a return from 2 to 6 percent in the first year, you’ve made a good investment. As you hold your investment property, you likely will be able to lower expenses and make some cosmetic improvements and minor upgrades to increase rental value. That’s when you’ll really see an impressive return. 


Capital Appreciation and Increasing Value

linear graph pertaining to increase of value

Most investors will not begin earning a return on their money in the first month that they own a rental property or even the first year. The market simply is too hot and the prices are too high. 


You’re still earning money. 


Consider capital appreciation, which is the increase of a home’s market value compared to its purchase price or acquisition cost. When you factor appreciation into your investment strategy, you’ll see that it will help you earn the income you’re hoping for as the property increases in value.  

You’re earning returns with tax benefits and having your tenants pay down your mortgage and contribute to other property-related expenses. 


Don’t get frustrated if it seems like you’re not earning what you want right now. A long term investment strategy is the best way to go when
you’re investing in San Diego real estate. If you’d like to talk this through, please contact us at Onyx Property Management, we have extensive knowledge on the San Diego property investment market.


Experienced San Diego property management professionals, Onyx Property Management serves the entire county, including San Diego, Chula Vista, Oceanside, Carlsbad, and the surrounding areas.

How Rental Property Inspections Protect Your Investment in La Jolla - Article Banner
By Onyx November 13, 2025
We’re a big fan of rental inspections and even maintenance walk-throughs when a tenant is occupying your property. That’s because they protect your investment.
Why is the San Diego Rental Market Getting Tougher? - Article Banner
By Onyx October 9, 2025
As most real estate investors and local owners may have noticed, the rental market is experiencing a shift, with properties taking longer to rent.
Strategies for Military Landlords in San Dieg - Article Banner
By Onyx September 11, 2025
We are here to help military landlords navigate these key areas while maximizing rental property value in San Diego.
Understanding the New California Balcony Inspection Law
By Onyx August 14, 2025
The California Balcony Inspection Law, also known as SB 721 and SB 326, is reshaping how landlords approach structural safety.
How Del Mar Landlords Can Raise Rent Without Losing Good Tenants - Article Banner
By Onyx July 10, 2025
With the right strategy, you can increase rent while maintaining tenant satisfaction and loyalty. I
How California’s Home Insurance Crisis is Impacting Landlords in Encinitas - Article Banner
By Onyx June 12, 2025
Let’s talk about how California’s home insurance crisis is impacting landlords in Encinitas, and what we can do about it.
Signs It’s Time to Switch Property Management Companies in San Diego
- Article Banner
By Onyx May 20, 2025
Let’s talk about the key signs that indicate it might be time to switch your property management company in San Diego.
California Landlord-Tenant Law Changes in 2025: Understanding AB 2347 and New Eviction Laws
By Onyx April 30, 2025
We’re talking about AB 2347, and the new eviction laws that California landlords must work around in order to remove a tenant from their rental property.
Risk Management for Multifamily Housing in San Diego, CA - Article Banner
By Onyx March 13, 2025
Let's discuss risk management and how to implement best practices for your multi-unit properties in San Diego.
San Diego Real Estate Investment Advice for Beginners - Article Banner
By Onyx February 13, 2025
As a new real estate investor, there’s a lot to consider. And we’re here to help you.